We love to imbibe! The clink of ice against glass, the hiss of a shaker, the glint of a perfectly chilled Old Fashioned—these moments make cocktail culture irresistible. Yet many of us sip without a clue about the drink’s lineage or why it bears its particular moniker. If you’ve ever wanted to wow friends with the juicy back‑stories of your favorite libations, you’ve landed in the right spot. Below is the top 10 classic lineup, each paired with the real history (and a few myths) that swirl around these iconic concoctions.
Why These Top 10 Classic Cocktails Matter
Every cocktail on this list has survived wars, Prohibition, and countless copy‑cats to become a staple of bars worldwide. Their stories reveal how culture, geography, and sheer serendipity shaped the drinks we still love today.
10 Manhattan
Popular legend claims that Winston Churchill’s mother ordered a “whiskey martini” at New York’s Manhattan Club, cheering the crowd as she sipped. That tale is pure fiction—Lady Randolph Churchill was actually pregnant on another continent when the supposed gathering took place. The truth is far more grounded: the Manhattan was birthed in the 1860s by a bartender named Black, who ran a cellar ten doors below Houston Street on Broadway. This account comes from William F. Mulhall, a long‑time steward of the famed Hoffman House, where the drink truly took shape. Despite the myth, the Manhattan Club still clings to the Churchill story, but the real origin remains anchored in Mulhall’s New York bar chronicles.
9 Margarita
The Margarita boasts at least half a dozen origin stories spanning 1936‑1961. One tale tells of a Dallas socialite who mixed it at a party attended by Tommy Hilton, later serving it in his hotels. Another claims a bartender improvised the drink for a Ziegfeld dancer allergic to all spirits except tequila. Both are apocryphal. The genuine lineage traces back to the Spanish word “daisy” (margarita), which described a family of cocktails originally made with brandy. During Prohibition, American tourists crossed the border, swapping brandy for tequila, and the modern Margarita emerged from this practical substitution.
8 Pina Colada
This tropical favorite is sometimes linked to the notorious Puerto Rican pirate Roberto Cofresi, who allegedly handed his crew a blend of coconut, pineapple, and rum for morale. While colorful, many establishments now lay claim to its invention. The most credible account credits Ramon “Monchito” Marrero, who painstakingly perfected the recipe while tending bar at the Caribbean Hilton Hotel. His creation coincided with the introduction of Coco Lopez, the key coconut cream, and the Puerto Rican government even celebrates Marrero and his bar as national treasures.
7 Aviation
Dubbed the “Bartender’s Handshake,” the Aviation first appeared in 1916, crafted by Hugo Ensslin at New York’s Hotel Warwick. A later controversy erupted when Harry Craddock, the “dean of cocktail shakers,” omitted the ethereal crème de violette from his 1930 Savoy Cocktail Book, sparking debate among purists. Today, the original recipe—featuring gin, maraschino liqueur, lemon juice, and a dash of violet liqueur—has enjoyed a renaissance, prized for its crisp, floral character.
6 Mint Julep
Hold your horses! In the 18th and 19th centuries, most cocktails were marketed as medicinal tonics, and the Mint Julep was no exception. Southern farmers drank it in the mornings, believing it would give them a “pep‑in‑their‑step.” Its earliest literary mentions date back to the 1780s. The drink vaulted to fame as the official cocktail of the Kentucky Derby in 1938, and today you’ll even find gilded cups priced at $1,000. Historically, the beverage was served in pewter or silver cups, held only by the rim to prevent the hand’s warmth from melting the icy crust. The term “julep” derives from the ancient Persian “galub,” meaning “flavored rosewater.”
5 Sidecar
This essential cocktail, listed among the six fundamentals every bartender should master (as per David Embury’s 1948 The Fine Art of Mixing Drinks), has a tangled backstory. Both London and Paris claim its invention, but the true home is New Orleans, the historic “cocktail capital of the past.” Legend says London’s Pat MacGarry brought the drink from Paris, where the Ritz and Harry’s New York Bar both assert ownership. Supposedly, a World War I army captain arrived at Harry’s riding a motorcycle sidecar and ordered the concoction. Some speculate the captain was actually from Louisiana and was requesting a “Brandy Crusta,” a drink dating to 1862.
4 Vieux Carre
Pronounced “voo‑ca‑ray,” the Vieux Carré fell out of favor during the 1970s‑80s as mixers dominated the scene. This potent blend of rye whiskey, cognac, sweet vermouth, Bénédictine, and bitters epitomizes New Orleans’ spirit. Its name literally translates to “French Quarter.” Though it involves six meticulous steps, the cocktail has surged back into vogue, now serving as a badge of honor for bartenders who can craft it from memory. Walter Bergeron invented it in 1938 while behind the bar at the historic Hotel Monteleone, whose rotating carousel bar adds an extra dash of drama to each pour.
3 Gin & Tonic
This seemingly simple mix played a pivotal role in the expansion of the British Empire. Gin originated as a medicinal elixir crafted by Dr. Sylvius de Bouve in 16th‑century Holland. In 1640, quinine bark from South America was processed into a syrup that prevented and cured malaria. When combined with carbonated water, the result was tonic water. British soldiers and East India Company personnel mixed their daily gin ration with quinine tonic to stave off malaria, giving birth to the classic Gin & Tonic that still refreshes palates worldwide.
2 Sazerac
Another New Orleans legend, the Sazerac, takes its name from the French cognac originally used in the recipe. Aaron Bird is credited with concocting the drink at the Sazerac Coffee House in the 1850s, aided by Antoine Amedie Peychaud, the creator of Peychaud’s bitters. Initially a cognac‑based cocktail, it underwent two major revisions in the 1870s: absinthe was added for aromatic depth, and rye whiskey replaced cognac after a phylloxera‑induced vineyard disaster in France halted cognac production. Peychaud also is said to have coined the word “cocktail,” measuring ingredients with a double‑sided egg cup—then called a “coquetier”—the ancestor of today’s jigger.
1 Old Fashioned
During Prohibition, many classic drinks were adulterated with excessive sweeteners and fruit. The Old Fashioned, however, remains a paragon of simplicity: a large ice cube, a sugar cube, a dash of bitters, a splash of water, a pour of bourbon or rye, and a single cherry garnish. Its first printed recipe appeared in 1862, and James E. Pepper is credited with introducing it from Louisville to New York’s Waldorf‑Astoria. This cocktail epitomizes the “old‑fashioned” philosophy—pure, unembellished, and timeless. While the Sazerac was still evolving with absinthe and rye, the Old Fashioned has stayed true to its roots.
Top 10 Drinking Games
About The Author: Former chef and bartender with 10 years of New York City restaurant experience.