Great Britain boasts a long, storied military past, but alongside glorious victories lie the blunders of some truly misguided commanders. In this roundup of the worst generals, we dive into ten British leaders whose poor decisions cost thousands of lives and left a lasting scar on history.
Why These Commanders Rank Among the Worst Generals
10 James Abercrombie

While Edward Braddock often bears the brunt for the Monongahela debacle, James Abercrombie earned his own notorious reputation during the French and Indian War. In July 1758 he ordered a frontal assault on Fort Ticonderoga that squandered thousands of men.
The terrain actually offered a clear path to flank the French position, with nearby hills perfect for artillery. Military historian Geoffrey Regan observes that Abercrombie faced “a range of options … any one of which guaranteed success.” Yet he chose a suicidal direct attack.
The result was a bloodbath: roughly 2,000 British troops fell, including nearly half of the famed Black Watch Highland regiment, and the assault was repulsed. Abercrombie was soon replaced by Edward Amherst, who captured Ticonderoga a year later with far fewer men and far less cost.
9 FitzRoy James Henry Somerset

The Crimean War (1853‑1856) stands as a textbook case of British military mismanagement, and at its helm was Lord Raglan, a former aide to the Duke of Wellington who proved wildly out of his depth. Cecil Woodham‑Smith notes that without his uniform “one would never have guessed him to be a soldier.”
At 65, Raglan was both senile and unhealthy, famously confusing the Russians with the French on several occasions. His inability to reconcile his cavalry commanders, Lucan and Cardigan, culminated in the infamous Charge of the Light Brigade at Balaclava.
Raglan’s blunders continued at the Alma, where he ordered repeated assaults on the same ground, allowing the Russians to escape. His troops then languished in trenches outside Sevastopol, succumbing to disease, cold, and inadequate supplies. Raglan himself died of dysentery in 1855.
8 Sir Redvers Buller

Byron Farwell once described Sir Redvers Buller as “a brave man who loved action but feared responsibility for the lives of others.” The British equivalent of Ambrose Burnside, Buller’s tenure in the Boer War was a parade of avoidable defeats.
Early in the conflict he delegated crucial responsibilities to Charles Warren, whose brigade blundered into a deadly cross‑fire at Spion Kop. With no artillery support, entrenching tools, or decisive leadership, the troops were pinned down.
Buller made no effort to reinforce Warren, even calling off a potentially decisive flank attack. While 1,700 men fought, a staggering 28,000 sat idle. When a Highland charge succeeded without his permission, Buller angrily ordered a withdrawal. In the end, about 1,500 men died needlessly, and both Buller and Warren were finally sacked.
7 William Howe

As Britain’s commander‑in‑chief during the American Revolutionary War, William Howe secured several battlefield victories, yet each came at a crushing strategic price.
At the Battle of Bunker Hill in June 1775, Howe’s forces won but suffered a 30 percent casualty rate. He then opted for a passive defense of Boston, choosing cards over campaigns and ultimately abandoning the city without a fight.
Howe’s triumphs on Long Island and the capture of New York City were offset by his hesitance to press the attack at Brooklyn Heights, allowing George Washington’s army to escape. Scattered outposts across New Jersey gave Washington easy wins at Trenton and Princeton.
The final fiasco came in 1777’s Saratoga Campaign. While General John Burgoyne pressed a pincer move in New York, Howe marched on Philadelphia, winning a costly victory at Brandywine but again letting Washington slip away. Burgoyne’s surrender at Saratoga brought France into the war, and Howe was subsequently dismissed.
6 John Whitelocke

Sir John Fortescue once called Whitelocke “bound up indissolubly with foolish expeditions.” After a career in the West Indies, he earned his place on this list for botching the 1807 Buenos Aires expedition, a side‑show of the Napoleonic Wars.
Whitelocke’s troops landed outside Buenos Aires on July 1 and routed a token Spanish force. Yet he delayed the follow‑up, giving the local militia time to organize. When his men finally entered the city, every window housed a sniper, artilleryman, or angry resident with boiling oil.
The British force was divided and attacked piecemeal. After a month of brutal street fighting, Whitelocke capitulated to Spanish General Liniares on August 12, having lost over 3,000 of his 10,000 men. Upon his return to England, he was cashiered.
5 Sir Charles Vere Ferrers Townshend

Charles Townshown proclaimed himself a genius on par with Napoleon, yet the 43,000‑man tragedy at the Siege of Kut tells a very different story. Driven by ambition, Townshend led his 6th Indian Division into what became Britain’s greatest World War I humiliation.
Ordered to advance on Baghdad in September 1915, Townshend privately expressed doubts but publicly leapt at the chance for glory, dreaming of governing Mesopotamia. After early successes, stiff Turkish resistance and heavy casualties halted his advance.
Instead of withdrawing to Basra as ordered, Townshend entrenched in the village of Kut. The ensuing 147‑day siege saw his troops endure starvation, cholera, and relentless Turkish attacks. He forbade sorties, claiming withdrawals would sap morale.
A relief force lost 23,000 men in a futile attempt to break the siege. In April 1916, Townshend finally surrendered. He enjoyed a comfortable captivity in Constantinople while his men suffered forced labor, and the British government even censored references to the disaster. Despite the ignominy, Townshend became a lieutenant‑general, knight, and MP, but history remembers him as an arrogant fool.
4 Arthur Percival

When Japan entered World II, Britain was preoccupied with Nazi Germany. The Japanese swiftly overran Hong Kong, Malaya, and Burma, but the crowning prize was Singapore—long touted as the “Gibraltar of the East.” Unfortunately for the Allies, the defender was the singularly inept Arthur Percival.
Percival commanded 85,000 Commonwealth troops against Yamashita’s 36,000 Japanese. Though outnumbered, his forces were overstretched, lacking tanks and modern aircraft. Obsessed with a naval defense—believing landward fortifications would “hurt morale”—he ceded the initiative to Yamashita, who slipped through the “impassable” Malay jungle and overwhelmed the British.
Faced with inevitable defeat, Percival surrendered, a move Winston Churchill later called “the worst disaster in British history.” Unlike Townshend, Percival endured imprisonment as badly as his men, and he became the only British lieutenant‑general ever to die without receiving a knighthood.
3 Sir Charles Maccarthy

What’s worse than surrendering an entire army? Destroying one outright. Sir Charles MacCarthy, governor of the Gold Coast, faced the powerful Ashanti tribe in 1824 and managed the campaign in a spectacularly comic fashion.
He split a 6,000‑man force into four uneven columns, keeping only 500 men under his direct command against a 10,000‑strong Ashanti force. When battle began on January 20, the other columns were miles away.
MacCarthy ordered his musicians to play “God Save the King,” hoping the anthem would frighten the Ashanti—an effort that failed spectacularly. As the battle raged, ammunition ran low, and when he called for reserves, he discovered only macaroni, not bullets.
The Ashanti overran the British, killing all but 20 survivors. MacCarthy himself was killed; his heart was reportedly eaten and his head used as a fetish for years. It took half a century of intermittent warfare to finally subdue the Ashanti.
2 William Hicks

Tasked with quelling the Mahdist uprising in Sudan, William Hicks led what Winston Churchill called “the worst army that has ever marched to war”—a rag‑tag mix of Egyptian prisoners and ex‑rebels, many shipped in shackles.
In the fall of 1883, Hicks marched his makeshift 10,000‑man force into Sudan. Misguided by treacherous guides, his army suffered desertion and dehydration. On November 3, the Mahdists—40,000 strong—pounced at the oasis of El Obeid. After two days of fierce fighting, Hicks’s army was overrun, with all but 500 men killed, including Hicks himself.
This catastrophic defeat paved the way for Charles Gordon’s doomed stand at Khartoum and ignited fifteen more years of brutal conflict in Sudan.
1 William George Keith Elphinstone

Britain’s first round in the Anglo‑Afghan War was a triumph, but the rebellion that followed forced the British into a nightmare. The man who led the catastrophe was William Elphinstone, the only commander ever to lose an entire British army.
Riddled with gout and heart disease, Elphinstone arrived in Kabul in 1842, only to find British camps set lower than the city walls, with supplies stored outside. Afghan bandits murdered anyone who ventured beyond the camp perimeter.
Indecisive and overly consultative, Elphinstone allowed Afghan forces to kill envoys, seize supplies, and harass his troops with impunity. He eventually agreed to withdraw, but the retreat through the Afghan mountains turned into a slaughter.
Disease, freezing weather, and constant attacks whittled the force down. In the Khyber Pass, Afghan fighters finally massacred the survivors. Of the 16,000 who left Kabul, only Dr. Brydon lived to tell the tale. Elphinstone himself died in captivity, earning George MacDonald Fraser’s description as “the greatest military idiot, of our own or any day.”

