10 International Historical Murder Mysteries That Still Baffle

by Johan Tobias

Murder may be a grim subject, but the international historical record is peppered with baffling cases that still capture imaginations. From remote Australian tree stumps to the dusty velds of South Africa, these ten unsolved mysteries showcase the strange ways crimes can slip through the cracks of justice.

International Historical Murder Mysteries Overview

10 Chrissie Venn Australia

Chrissie Venn case - international historical murder mystery image

On March 1, 1921, the body of 13‑year‑old Chrissie Venn was discovered in a hollow tree stump near North Motton, Tasmania, after she vanished on February 20 while running errands. Newspaper reports initially claimed she was murdered on February 21 and that her body was mutilated, but later updates shifted the date to February 26 and described her death as strangulation or suffocation with only defensive wounds.

Suspicion fell on George William King, a 35‑year‑old former miner and policeman, who had been seen in the area and reportedly tried to speak with Chrissie on several occasions. He also had scratches on his hands, which he said came from participating in a search party.

A search of King’s home uncovered an anonymous letter accusing him of the murder and urging confession, though the author never came forward. At trial, King’s lawyer Albert Ogilvie—future Tasmanian premier—argued that the circumstantial witnesses were unreliable, securing a not‑guilty verdict. Chrissie’s murder remains unsolved.

9 Hinterkaifeck Murders Germany

In the early 20th century, Hinterkaifeck was the unofficial name of a farmstead situated between two Bavarian cities, now part of Waidhofen. On March 31, 1922, all six residents were brutally slain, making it one of Germany’s most notorious unsolved crimes.

The victims included farm owner Andreas Gruber, his wife Cazilia, their daughter Viktoria, grandchildren Cazilia and Josef, and maid Maria Baumgartner. Investigators concluded the murder weapon was likely a mattock—a pick‑axe‑like tool with an axe blade.

Four victims were found in the barn, apparently lured and killed one by one. The killer then moved inside the house, murdering baby Josef and the maid. Though robbery was initially suspected, valuables and cash were still inside, leading police to dismiss theft as motive. Neighbors reported seeing chimney smoke after the murders, suggesting the perpetrator lingered on the farm.

Andreas Gruber had complained of odd occurrences—forest footprints leading to the house, strange attic noises, and disappearing keys—yet never reported them. The farm was demolished in 1923, hampering later investigations. Over 100 suspects were questioned, but no one was ever charged.

8 Janet Smith Canada

Janet Smith case - international historical murder mystery image

Between 1924 and 1925, Vancouver headlines repeatedly asked, “Who killed Janet Smith?” Born in Scotland in 1902, Smith worked as a nursemaid for the affluent Bakers. On July 26, 1924, she was found with a bullet wound to the head and a revolver near her outstretched arm.

See also  10 Historical Figures Remembered for the Wrong Reason

Police and the coroner quickly labeled the death a suicide, sparking accusations of a cover‑up. The Vancouver Star was among the first to allege police corruption. After the attorney general ordered a reopening, Smith’s body was exhumed and the death re‑classified as murder.

The Bakers’ Chinese houseboy, Wong Foon Sing, became the prime suspect after claims that Smith rebuffed his romantic advances. Some believed authorities were pinning the crime on an easy target. The case took a shocking turn when KKK members kidnapped, imprisoned, and tortured Sing for six weeks to force a confession. Charges were eventually dropped, and Sing returned to Hong Kong.

Rumors swirled about wealthy playboy Jack Nicol raping and killing Smith, or the household’s head, Frederick Baker, silencing her after she discovered his smuggling operation. No one was ever formally charged.

7 Kyllikki Saari Finland

Kyllikki Saari case - international historical murder mystery image

On May 17, 1953, 17‑year‑old Kyllikki Saari was murdered while walking home from the local church in Isojoki. A month later, her bicycle was recovered in a marshy area near her route, and on October 11 her body was found nearby.

Saari’s death sparked massive outrage; tens of thousands attended her funeral, and thousands more petitioned the Finnish government to reinstate the death penalty so her killer could be hanged. The first promising lead involved a local farmer who asked whether police had found Saari’s missing shoes—a detail not yet public—making him a prime suspect. He provided an airtight alibi and was cleared.

Further investigations turned up several suspects, including Hans Assmann, a German immigrant alleged to have served in the SS during World War II before becoming a KGB spy. On his deathbed in 1997, Assmann confided to editor and former police officer Matti Paloaro that his driver may have accidentally run Saari over, and that they covered up the murder. No one was ever charged.

6 Josslyn Hay Kenya

Josslyn Hay case - international historical murder mystery image

The deaths of the rich and famous always generate headlines, and the murder of Josslyn Hay, Earl of Erroll, was no exception. Born into a diplomatic British family, Hay scandalized society in 1923 by marrying Lady Idina Sackville, a socialite who divorced her second husband to be with him.

To escape the scandal, the couple moved to Kenya and joined the “Happy Valley Set,” a circle of wealthy whites known for decadent parties. On January 24, 1941, Hay was found shot dead in his car on the Nairobi‑Ngong road.

During his Kenyan years, Hay divorced Lady Idina, married a second wife who died in 1939, and was involved in an affair with Lady Diana Broughton. Sir Delves Broughton, Lady Diana’s husband, was arrested and charged with the murder but was acquitted for lack of evidence. Broughton later committed suicide, fueling speculation about his guilt.

See also  10 People Killed by Their Own Booby Traps in Real Life

Other suspects have been proposed, including Lady Diana herself, fellow Happy Valley member Alice de Janze (a former mistress of Hay with a violent history), and even MI6, which may have wanted Hay dead for his affiliation with a British fascist party.

5 C.N. Lakshmikanthan India

C.N. Lakshmikanthan case - international historical murder mystery image

In 1944, the Tamil‑language film world—Kollywood—was rocked by the murder of C.N. Lakshmikanthan, a prominent tabloid journalist. Three of the industry’s biggest stars—producer‑director Sriramulu Naidu, comedian N.S. Krishnan, and leading actor M.K. Thyagaraja Bhagavathar—were implicated.

Lakshmikanthan’s columns frequently targeted these figures. Allegedly, they hired men to attack him while he rode in a rickshaw. He was stabbed and later died at the hospital. Remarkably, before reaching the hospital, Lakshmikanthan stopped at a police station, reported the assault, and named his attackers.

Six people were arrested, including the three stars. Naidu was eventually cleared, but Bhagavathar and Krishnan were convicted and sentenced to life transportation. After appeals to the Privy Council, the Madras High Court reopened the case, finding both men innocent. They were released in 1947 after serving 30 months, but the conviction devastated their careers and health. The murder remains unsolved.

4 Lintz Green Murder England

Lintz Green stationmaster case - international historical murder mystery image

Lintz Green railway station, operating from 1867 to 1953 in Durham, is now chiefly remembered for the shocking 1911 murder of its stationmaster, Joseph Wilson. On October 7, 1911, the 60‑year‑old Wilson was shot while returning home after closing the station. He died before medical help could arrive.

Robbery appeared to be the motive, as Wilson habitually carried the day’s takings. Curiously, he had already transferred the money earlier that day for unknown reasons. Hundreds of officers joined one of the largest investigations in Northeast England, yet police produced no solid leads.

Under intense scrutiny, a breakthrough pointed to Samuel Atkinson, a porter at Lintz Green, who was seen lingering after his shift. However, lacking concrete evidence, Atkinson was released after preliminary hearings. No other strong suspects emerged, leaving the case forever open.

3 Moll McCarthy Ireland

Moll McCarthy case - international historical murder mystery image

Between November 20 and 21, 1940, Marlhill prostitute Mary “Moll” McCarthy was shot dead in her home. Neighbor Henry Gleeson, who discovered the body, was later convicted and hanged for the murder.

Police claimed Gleeson was the father of McCarthy’s youngest child; when the infant died six weeks after birth, Gleeson allegedly killed McCarthy out of anger. The case was presented as an open‑and‑shut conviction, but many believed Gleeson was a scapegoat.

See also  Top 10 Mysteries Still Unsolved in 2019 That Puzzle Us

In 2015, almost 75 years after his execution, Gleeson received a posthumous pardon from the Irish president. The Department of Justice highlighted numerous flaws: an incorrect time of death, omission of favorable witnesses, and other procedural errors. Moreover, McCarthy’s own daughter, Mary, confessed on her deathbed that she witnessed her mother’s murder and that an innocent man was executed.

Speculation about the real killer points to one of McCarthy’s other children’s fathers—possibly a Garda captain—or local IRA members who may have targeted her as an alleged informant.

2 Markovic Affair France

One of the 20th century’s biggest political scandals—the Markovic affair—combined sex, drugs, murder, and celebrity. It began with the death of Stefan Markovic, a bodyguard for actor Alain Delon. Delon, a European heartthrob famed for wild parties, allegedly introduced Markovic to the underworld of drug trafficking, where he reportedly tried to pass off white powder as heroin.

On October 1, 1968, Markovic’s body was found in a sack atop a garbage heap. A letter he sent to his brother blamed his death on Alain Delon and Delon’s godfather, François Marcantoni. Marcantoni, a self‑described reformed gangster, was charged as an accomplice but later released. Delon was never charged, though he was questioned several times.

Markovic also allegedly blackmailed party guests by photographing them in compromising situations. Rumors suggested he targeted Madame Pompidou, wife of presidential candidate Georges Pompidou. Those rumors were used to portray the scandal as a plot by de Gaulle supporters to undermine Pompidou’s campaign.

1 Bubbles Schroeder South Africa

Bubbles Schroeder case - international historical murder mystery image

On August 17, 1949, the strangled body of 18‑year‑old Jacoba “Bubbles” Schroeder was discovered in the veld near Johannesburg. Her shoes, coat, and hat were missing, and a chalky white substance had been forced down her throat. Though her body bore scratch marks, there were no footprints or signs of a struggle.

That night, Bubbles went out with friends Morris Bilchik and David Polliack. The trio ended up at Polliack’s house, where Bubbles met Hyman Liebman. After dinner and drinks, Bilchik left, and Liebman briefly stepped out to meet his girlfriend. When he returned, Polliack offered to take Bubbles home, but she entered Liebman’s car and refused to leave. She demanded to be let out when Liebman refused to let her drive—her last known moment.

Liebman and Polliack were arrested as the last people to see her alive, but without evidence, they were acquitted. One theory suggests a passing motorist who offered her a lift killed her after she rebuffed his advances; her underwear was torn, supporting a possible sexual motive.

Radu, a history‑science enthusiast, encourages readers to share this tale on Twitter or explore his website for more obscure stories.

You may also like

Leave a Comment