When it comes to the world of the bizarre, the 10 creepy items that command sky‑high price tags are the stuff of nightmares and curiosity alike. From haunted canvases drenched in blood to diamonds shrouded in curses, these objects prove that some collectors will pay a fortune for a good scare.
10 creepy items: A Quick Overview
10 The Cursed Artwork Painted With Blood
The oil painting known as The Anguished Man first surfaced in a chilling tale from northern England. Sean Robinson recounted that his grandmother had stored the canvas in her attic for a quarter‑century, during which she reported a slew of unsettling paranormal activity inside her home.
She described seeing a dark, sorrowful figure emerging from the canvas and hearing unsettling noises, including soft sobbing. Legend has it that the man depicted in the work took his own life and mixed his own blood with the oil paints, giving the piece its macabre reputation.
After the grandmother passed away, Sean inherited the artwork and placed it in his basement. Not long after, the same eerie whispers and mournful cries began echoing through his house, mirroring his grandmother’s experiences. She had warned him that the painting was malevolent, but neither he nor his family were prepared for the intensity of the hauntings.
While the piece could once be purchased for a staggering £1,500, it is no longer on the market. Its reputation as an unholy canvas has kept it firmly out of any ordinary collector’s living room.
9 Year-Old Woman’s Soul
This unsettling porcelain figure emerged on eBay, advertised as being possessed by the spirit of a 20‑year‑old woman named Diana. The seller claims that the doll, which shares Diana’s name, constantly generates bizarre phenomena for those who keep it nearby.
According to the vendor, owners have reported neighbors spotting phantom children and swings moving on their own without any visible cause. Supposedly, Diana is a devotee of feminine accessories, adding an extra layer of eerie charm to the doll’s presence.
While the evidence remains anecdotal at best, anyone daring enough to purchase this haunted doll would need to be exceptionally brave. Priced at $1,250, the cost is steep for a piece of porcelain that might just sit silently in a corner—unless it decides to stir up mischief.
8 1:1 Annabelle Replica
Another eBay find, this meticulously crafted replica of the infamous Annabelle doll, is touted as having no inherent paranormal powers. However, its design draws heavily from The Conjuring and Annabelle movies, which themselves were inspired by the real‑life investigations of demonologists Ed and Lorraine Warren.
Although the authentic Annabelle differs from this prop, the replica’s lifelike features give it a genuinely unsettling vibe. The original doll was known to appear in various locations throughout a household, earning its reputation as one of the most haunted objects in history. The replica, priced at nearly $2,500, carries that same chilling aura without the documented hauntings.
7 The Psycho Pot
A pot? Yes, an old, rusted metal pot that once belonged to infamous 1950s serial killer Ed Gein.
Gein’s gruesome legacy includes murdering people, skinning their bodies, and repurposing the remains into clothing and household items. This particular pot was allegedly used to store body parts, making it a macabre relic directly linked to the horror that inspired films like The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and The Silence of the Lambs.
The pot is not a movie replica but the genuine article, purchased by paranormal investigator Zak Bagans from the show Ghost Adventures. He paid $2,800 for the piece after acquiring it from a woman who had used it as a flower pot. Whether he regrets owning such a haunted artifact remains to be seen.
6 The Black Orlov Diamond
Among the priciest entries on our list, the Black Orlov diamond fetched a jaw‑dropping $352,000 at a 2006 auction. Its estimated value continues to climb, and today it could be worth roughly $1 million. Though the curse associated with the stone is said to have been broken, its dark past still sends shivers down the spine.
Originally sourced from India, the gem is rumored to have once formed the eye of a statue of Brahma, the Hindu creator deity. After being stolen, the diamond became linked to three mysterious suicides among its successive owners, cementing its reputation as a cursed jewel.
The stone was recut in the 1950s—a process believed to have shattered the curse. Actress Felicity Huffman even wore the diamond at the 2006 Oscars. Despite its glamorous moments, the Black Orlov’s haunting history remains undeniably chilling.
5 Dr. Kevorkian’s Van
This rust‑covered 1968 Volkswagen van once belonged to the controversial Dr. Jack Kevorkian, famously dubbed the “Death Bus” by some observers.
Bagans, ever the collector of eerie artifacts, added the van to his personal museum after acquiring it for $32,500. The vehicle served as the backdrop for many of Kevorkian’s roughly 130 assisted‑suicide procedures, lending it a grim aura that fits perfectly among other haunted curiosities.
Although the van no longer starts, Bagans is content with his purchase, displaying it alongside other macabre items in his paranormal‑themed collection.
4 The Crying Boy Painting
Created by an Italian artist, The Crying Boy is a mass‑produced artwork that quickly garnered a reputation for being cursed. Stories claim that homes featuring the painting suffered mysterious injuries, the sound of children’s cries in childless houses, and frequent house fires that left the canvas untouched.
While skeptics point to a special fire‑resistant coating on the paint as a possible explanation, the legend endures. Original versions of the painting can command prices exceeding $5,000, far more than a typical print, making it a pricey addition to any collection—if you dare.
3 Michael Jackson’s Chair
As its name suggests, this chair once occupied Michael Jackson’s “death room.” It was used by his physician to monitor the pop star while he was administered propofol, the anesthetic that ultimately caused his untimely demise.
Paranormal investigator Zak Bagans purchased the chair for roughly $15,000, noting that it still bears faint makeup stains from the singer. While it’s unclear whether the seat has manifested any supernatural activity, owning a piece of MJ’s final moments is undeniably unsettling.
2 The Basano Vase
At first glance, the Basano vase appears to be a simple, elegant Italian silver piece. Yet its history tells a far darker tale.
Crafted in the 15th century, the vase is believed to have been a wedding gift for a young Italian bride. On the night before—or perhaps the morning after—her wedding, the bride was discovered either dying or already dead, clutching the vase in her hands.
Since that tragic event, the vase has been linked to numerous untimely deaths and has passed through many owners, earning a reputation as a cursed heirloom. Sold in the late 1980s for 4 million lire (about $2,500 at the time), its value has likely risen considerably in the decades since.
1 The Hands Resist Him
The unsettling painting The Hands Resist Him, created by Bill Stoneham in 1974, holds the distinction of being the most affordable entry on our list at $1,025.
The legend began when a young girl repeatedly told her father that the children depicted in the artwork were fighting. To prove otherwise, the father set up a motion‑sensitive camera, only to capture footage of the boy in the painting crawling out into the real world.
Since then, the piece has been linked to feelings of unease, unexplained illnesses, and a slew of paranormal phenomena—including sudden blasts of hot air and three documented deaths. Some claim that merely viewing the original eBay listing triggered eerie happenings in their homes.
Just a curious guy who loves to write!